Skip to content

Agenda: content/drafts/dt-overview/survey.md

Review aid, not a gate. This report is evidence for a human judgement, never a verdict. A driver may read it back; no draft is blocked by what it says. See SOUL.md, and docs/ARCHITECTURE.md's "Layer 4: the review layer".

  • Draft: content/drafts/dt-overview/survey.md
  • Command: python -m chitragupta.review agenda content/drafts/dt-overview/survey.md
  • chitragupta 6.166.1

How to read this

This is a review aid, not a gate: every item below is evidence for a human judgement, ranked by class and then severity, never a verdict. unattended items are ones a future agenda-reviser may act on without asking first; every other item is surfaced for a person to decide.

Sources

  • Citation provenance: read
  • Verbatim scan: read
  • Citation coverage: read
  • Multi-source synthesis: read, no item class defined
  • TikZ layout check: not run
  • Uncited prose: read
  • Quotation integrity: read
  • Claim support: read
  • Prose (style_check): read
  • Dossier drift: read
  • Recorded-but-uncited citekeys: read
  • Accepted items: none recorded for this draft

Summary

  • 11 verbatim-run
  • 8 unsupported-claim
  • 8 uncited-claim

Findings

verbatim-run

  • 6bdcbebedc51 [unattended] (1. Introduction): 13-word verbatim run citing sample_dt_overview_2024

    source p.1, draft line 7, paragraph 3

    a digital model exchanges data with its physical counterpart only through manual steps

  • 84cebc824e5b [unattended] (1. Introduction): 15-word skip-gram match citing sample_dt_overview_2024, 6 matched

    source p.1, draft line 12, paragraph 3

    draft -- synthetic survey of forty deployments twenty eight systems described as twins were by this definition

    source -- synthetic survey of forty deployments, twenty-eight systems described as twins were, by the definition

  • a5c3ae10b25d [unattended] (1. Introduction): 13-word verbatim run citing sample_dt_overview_2024

    source p.1, draft line 12, paragraph 3

    synthetic survey of forty deployments twenty eight systems described as twins were by

  • 15443321c043 [unattended] (2. Keeping the twin true): 9-word verbatim run citing sample_dt_sync_2023

    source p.1, draft line 22, paragraph 6

    twin is only as trustworthy as its last synchronisation

  • 3e716e1cee1c [unattended] (2. Keeping the twin true): 17-word skip-gram match citing sample_dt_sync_2023, 8 matched

    source p.1, draft line 23, paragraph 6

    draft -- across nine simulated production cells event driven synchronisation reduced transmitted volume by 71 percent against one second

    source -- across nine simulated production cells, event-driven flows reduced transmitted volume by 71 percent against one-second

  • b0c514d34af4 [unattended] (2. Keeping the twin true): 9-word verbatim run citing sample_dt_sync_2023

    source p.1, draft line 24, paragraph 6

    reduced transmitted volume by 71 percent against one second

  • 539fac477a87 [unattended] (2. Keeping the twin true): 9-word verbatim run citing sample_dt_sync_2023

    source p.1, draft line 28, paragraph 6

    both during slow thermal drift that never crossed its

  • dc32161a46ac [unattended] (2. Keeping the twin true): 13-word verbatim run citing sample_dt_sync_2023

    source p.1, draft line 32, paragraph 7

    a twin that knows it is stale must say so on every read

  • 91bce1eac368 [unattended] (2. Keeping the twin true): 13-word skip-gram match citing sample_dt_factory_2022, 5 matched

    source p.1, draft line 37, paragraph 7

    draft -- showing supervisors agreeing with the twin in over ninety five percent of cases

    source -- showed supervisors agreeing with the twin’s choice in over ninety-five percent

  • 3acc4d59f0b1 [unattended] (4. Integrating with everything else): 11-word verbatim run citing sample_std_interop_2021

    source p.1, draft line 58, paragraph 11

    twin pilots rarely die of modelling problems they die of integration

  • 1561cffaa101 [unattended] (4. Integrating with everything else): 10-word verbatim run citing sample_std_interop_2021

    source p.1, draft line 63, paragraph 11

    integrated a new asset in a median of six days

unsupported-claim

  • 401e348db58b [surfaced] (6. Conclusion): [@sample_dt_factory_2022] scores no support found: Across the sample corpus, the recurring finding is that twins succeed on honesty
  • e7b94c624d1f [surfaced] (6. Conclusion): [@sample_ml_anomaly_2023] scores no support found: Across the sample corpus, the recurring finding is that twins succeed on honesty
  • 8fdd2ee4868e [surfaced] (6. Conclusion): [@sample_std_interop_2021] scores no support found: Across the sample corpus, the recurring finding is that twins succeed on honesty
  • 289df3c9be7c [surfaced] (5. Gaps): [@sample_dt_overview_2024] scores weak: Fidelity is argued to be purchased "decision by decision", yet no paper offers a
  • 3df8a2924fc8 [surfaced] (5. Gaps): [@sample_dt_factory_2022] scores weak: And the organisational trust mechanisms of the factory study have no counterpart
  • df03e928650d [surfaced] (5. Gaps): [@sample_ml_anomaly_2023] scores weak: And the organisational trust mechanisms of the factory study have no counterpart
  • a1971eb28d62 [surfaced] (6. Conclusion): [@sample_dt_overview_2024] scores weak: Across the sample corpus, the recurring finding is that twins succeed on honesty
  • ec64b9c0aa2e [surfaced] (6. Conclusion): [@sample_dt_sync_2023] scores weak: Across the sample corpus, the recurring finding is that twins succeed on honesty

uncited-claim

  • 491fe09dcc87 [surfaced] (1. Introduction): This survey groups the sample corpus into three themes -- keeping the twin true
  • 91bd35436e62 [surfaced] (1. Introduction): The phrase digital twin is applied to systems with very different levels of am
  • 89452ab2d5ad [surfaced] (2. Keeping the twin true): A twin is only as trustworthy as its last synchronisation.
  • 7823f44ba5ae [surfaced] (2. Keeping the twin true): Trust is behavioural as much as technical.
  • 6531eaa55379 [surfaced] (3. Using the state stream): Once a twin exists, its state stream is a naturally clean substrate for analytic
  • bb027cc3f4cf [surfaced] (4. Integrating with everything else): Twin pilots rarely die of modelling problems; they die of integration.
  • 13645296d189 [surfaced] (5. Gaps): Three gaps stand out.
  • a65e62d24215 [surfaced] (5. Gaps): The corpus measures synchronisation and anomaly detection separately, but no pap