Verbatim scan: content/drafts/dt-overview/survey.md¶
Review aid, not a gate. This report is evidence for a human judgement, never a verdict. A driver may read it back; no draft is blocked by what it says. See SOUL.md, and docs/ARCHITECTURE.md's "Layer 4: the review layer".
- Draft:
content/drafts/dt-overview/survey.md - Command:
python -m chitragupta.review verbatim scan content/drafts/dt-overview/survey.md --min-run 8 --gap 1 --write - chitragupta 6.61.7
- Allowlist: none configured (
content/verbatim_allowlist.tomlnot found)
How to read this¶
Every run of at least --min-run words this draft shares with any
parsed source in the corpus, cited or not. Sharing wording is not by
itself misconduct -- a defined term, a standard's name and a correctly
quoted sentence all show up here -- so each finding is a place to look,
not a charge.
Two flags narrow the reading:
- UNCITED SOURCE -- the paragraph the run sits in does not cite the
source it matched. That is the finding
overlapstructurally cannot make, and the one most worth reading first. - quoted -- the run touches quote delimiters, so it is most likely a deliberate quotation. A run is usually wider than the quotation inside it -- it can open in the draft's own framing prose -- so this reads as overlap, not containment.
Each finding names its tier: exact is a verbatim run; skip-gram
is a tolerant stemmed-subsequence match that also catches a passage
with a handful of words substituted. A skip-gram finding's word count
is matched words / span: how many words the tier actually matched,
out of the raw width of text those matches span -- the two can differ
a lot, since a skip-gram window can stretch across stopwords and
opposite-family words that were not themselves matched.
embedding is the third tier: a sentence-level alignment between a
section of this draft and the sources its dossier records that section
as written from. It matches meaning rather than wording, so it is the
only tier that can see a genuine restatement -- and the only one whose
findings are not reproducible from the draft and the corpus alone,
since the vectors change with [enrich].embedding_model. Its score
is that alignment's strength, not a probability and not comparable to
anything the other two report; a passage a deterministic tier already
flagged is left to that tier rather than reported twice.
Findings below are grouped most-damning-first: long runs, then short
ones, then quoted runs -- but a quoted run only drops into the last
group when it also cites the source it matched. A quoted run from an
uncited source is still grouped by length (on matched words, not raw
span), not buried under quoted.
The allowlist bullet above names a per-host, gitignored file
(content/verbatim_allowlist.toml, see docs/PLAGIARISM.md) of
boilerplate this host's owner has decided never to flag -- a run is
only dropped when what's left after discounting the allowlisted text
would no longer clear --min-run on its own, so a real lift that
merely contains a defined term still shows up below.
A clean run is not a clean bill of health. This draft has been checked against all three tiers, but they do not cover the same ground: the two deterministic ones see wording, and the embedding tier sees meaning only within each section's own recorded sources. Reuse from a source a section's dossier does not record is outside what any of the three can find by restatement alone. See docs/PLAGIARISM.md.
Findings¶
11 run(s), grouped most-damning-first.
Short runs¶
17 words, 8 matched -- sample_dt_sync_2023 p.1 (tier=skip-gram)¶
across nine simulated production cells event driven synchronisation reduced transmitted volume by 71 percent against one second
In context: threshold push and event driven flows across nine simulated production cells event driven synchronisation reduced transmitted volume by 71 percent against one second polling while holding worst case staleness...
15 words, 6 matched -- sample_dt_overview_2024 p.1 (tier=skip-gram)¶
synthetic survey of forty deployments twenty eight systems described as twins were by this definition
In context: strictly keeps expectations honest in one synthetic survey of forty deployments twenty eight systems described as twins were by this definition shadows this survey groups the sample...
13 words, 5 matched -- sample_dt_factory_2022 p.1 (tier=skip-gram)¶
showing supervisors agreeing with the twin in over ninety five percent of cases
In context: accuracy but a published override log showing supervisors agreeing with the twin in over ninety five percent of cases both failures it records were silent...
13 words -- sample_dt_overview_2024 p.1 (tier=exact)¶
a digital model exchanges data with its physical counterpart only through manual steps
In context: here begins by fixing that vocabulary a digital model exchanges data with its physical counterpart only through manual steps a digital shadow adds an automatic...
13 words -- sample_dt_overview_2024 p.1 (tier=exact)¶
synthetic survey of forty deployments twenty eight systems described as twins were by
In context: strictly keeps expectations honest in one synthetic survey of forty deployments twenty eight systems described as twins were by this definition shadows this survey groups...
13 words -- sample_dt_sync_2023 p.1 (tier=exact)¶
a twin that knows it is stale must say so on every read
In context: much as technical marking staleness explicitly a twin that knows it is stale must say so on every read roughly halved operator mistrust incidents in...
11 words -- sample_std_interop_2021 p.1 (tier=exact)¶
twin pilots rarely die of modelling problems they die of integration
In context: model 4 integrating with everything else twin pilots rarely die of modelling problems they die of integration interoperability requires agreement at three layers...
10 words -- sample_std_interop_2021 p.1 (tier=exact)¶
integrated a new asset in a median of six days
In context: named owners sites that maintained one integrated a new asset in a median of six days against seven weeks where semantics were...
9 words -- sample_dt_sync_2023 p.1 (tier=exact)¶
twin is only as trustworthy as its last synchronisation
In context: 2 keeping the twin true a twin is only as trustworthy as its last synchronisation comparing periodic pull threshold push and...
9 words -- sample_dt_sync_2023 p.1 (tier=exact)¶
reduced transmitted volume by 71 percent against one second
In context: simulated production cells event driven synchronisation reduced transmitted volume by 71 percent against one second polling while holding worst case staleness...
9 words -- sample_dt_sync_2023 p.1 (tier=exact)¶
both during slow thermal drift that never crossed its
In context: study s two worst staleness excursions both during slow thermal drift that never crossed its configured delta trust is behavioural as...